French study offers insight on emotional issues and prostate cancer
Vive la France prostate researchers
By Howard Wolinsky
A new French study in a big-deal journal is showing that surprisingly—to me anyway— that patients with localized prostate cancer who go on active surveillance have just as much and maybe a bit more anxiety than patients who opt for radiation therapy or surgery.
Also, the French researchers found that in patients who opt for radiation tend to be more depressed than those who choose AS or prostatectomy.
The French seem to be breaking new ground: “Few studies have focused on anxiety and depressive symptoms experienced by men undergoing AS for prostate cancer.” I have mainly seen studies on anxiety.
Reporting in Nature: Davidson Sypre, MD, of the Department of Surgical Oncology, Institut Paoli-Calmettes in Marseille, France, and his colleagues reported that in a study group of about 300 with localized prostate cancer, 14.9% reported receiving “curative treatment” five years after being diagnosed.
The French patients fared much better than patients in U.S. studies. The finding contrasts with a multi-center study headed by researchers from Northwestern that found that 33.4% converted to treatment at a median follow-up of 6.7 years. A Canadian study was even higher at nearly 50% dropout rates at 48 months into AS.
[I will be writing more about the dropout rate soon.]
The French study found that anxiety was reported by 34.3% of patients on AS vs. 28.6% in the radical prostatectomy group and 31.6% in the radiation therapy group.
So anxiety levels were slightly higher in low-risk patients who opted for AS.
The French study was a bit unusual in that it looked at depression.
The incidence of depression was highest in the group that underwent radiation therapy and lowest in the AS group.
Depressive symptoms were found in 14.9% of cases in the AS group vs. 10.7% in the radical prostatectomy group and 22.8% of cases in the radiation therapy group.
The French researchers said: “In patients with PC managed by AS, intolerance of uncertainty is a predisposing trait for anxiety marked by the tendency to perceive uncertainty as threatening. The patients may experience feelings of anxiety and distress while living with ‘untreated’ cancer.
“The establishment of close monitoring with regular PSA testing, digital rectal examination, prostate MRI and biopsies as an integral part of AS could exacerbate perceptions of threat and therefore cause concern1 Yet, the management of this anxiety, therefore, seems essential in order to allow better patient adherence to this treatment modality.”
I am not sure if cross-cultural research applies. I just reported on an Italian-Dutch study with surprising results.
I asked Risa Liang Wong, MD, a hematology oncologist in the Genitourinary Oncology Program at the University of Pittsburgh, said in an interview here:
Is there any difference between how they impact men with low-risk vs. high-risk prostate cancer?
Wong said: I have not come across any research suggesting that, for example, men with higher risk localized prostate cancer experience more depression, anxiety, or distress than men with lower risk localized prostate cancer. If you are aware of any such research, please let me know. My suspicion is that a diagnosis of prostate cancer is always upsetting, and may cause significant levels of distress regardless of whether considered lower or high risk.
The tools are available to screen us for anxiety and depression as Richard Maye, a former administrator of mental health facilities, pointed out in a column in the Active Surveillor last month.
Can psychotherapy, medication, meditation, or exercise help? Are urologists, medical oncologists, radiation oncologists and family physicians, for that matter, sensitive to these problems?
Maye noted that the PHQ-9 (Anxiety scale) and the GAD-7(Depression scale) are well-known behavioral health assessment tools completed by the patient in the office while waiting to see the physician or at home prior to their visit.
The American Urological Association told me that a webinar on emotions and PCa is planned for this fall. The Prostate Cancer Foundation is planning a webinar on the topic next month. (See below.) Something is afoot at Prostate Cancer UK as well.
I suspect doctors downplay the effects of emotional issues on cancer patients in general as they focus on urinary and sexual function.
I can’t prove it. But I am involved in a project to examine these issues through a patient survey. Stay tuned.
Meanwhile, if you have anxiety or depression stemming from your prostate cancer diagnosis, get help.
For those on AS, remember what a psychologist told me: “A prostatectomy is not a solution for anxiety.”
Background. (Brag warning):
Howard Wolinsky has been a medical reporter for more than 50 years. He specialized in mental health issues for the Kankakee (Illinois) Journal covering the transfer to the community of massive numbers of patients from large mental hospitals. These patients faced major challenges as they were dumped on the streets of impoverished areas in Chicago.
The American Bar Association honored this work on the abuse of mental patients in its Silver Gavel competition in 1972.
Likewise, the Bar Association of the 7th Federal District recognized this work.
U.S. Supreme Court Justice Thurgood Marshall presented the award to Wolinsky’s boss in a ceremony in Chicago.
Marshall told Managing Editor Roy Barron: “You can brag now. You’re not under oath.”
The National Mental Health Association and the Mental Health Association in Illinois also have honored Wolinsky’s work in the mental health field
The Chicago Sun-Times nominated Wolinsky twice for the Pulitzer Prize for exposes on financial and ethical scandals at the American Medical Association.
Please join AnCan’s Virtual Support Group for Patients on Active Surveillance for a program, “Prostate Cancer Biopsies...The Great Debate,” on whether transrectal biopsies or transperineal biopsies are better for patients.
The program will be 8-9:30 p.m. Eastern on August 29. Register here: https://register.gotowebinar.com/register/1375984251183869452
Deborah Kaye, MD, Assistant Professor Duke UniversityDivision of Urology and Duke Clinical Research Institute Margolis Policy Center, will argue for transrectal biopsies.
Arvin George, MD, a urologic surgeon specializing in the diagnosis and management of genitourinary cancers at the University of Michigan Health, will argue for transperineal procedures.
Co-sponsors include ASPI, Prostate Cancer Support Canada, the Prostate Forum of Orange County, and TheActiveSurveillor.com.
Please submit questions in advance to moderator Joe Gallo at joeg@ancan.org
Also, check out a program on genetic testing by Active Surveillance Patients International.
Here’s the scoop:
HOW AND WHEN SHOULD I DO A GENETICS TEST?
ASPI: August 27 @ 12:00 pm - 1:30 pm EDT
Men, loved ones, and families can gain valuable facts from a cancer genetic test. While the use of genetics testing for cancers is still growing, the existing state of the art for prostate and related cancers is a powerful tool for identifying men and persons at risk. This 60-minute expert presentation will feature Robert Finch, MS, a Certified Genetic Counselor, and medical oncologist Michael Glode, MD.
You will be reacquainted with prostate cancer screening biomarkers such as the PSA test and a variety of genomic tests, receive a thorough explanation of how and when to get a cancer genetics test along with genomics tests, and finally a moment for you the patient or family to ask questions.
As ASPI does not provide medical advice, this program will educate you and your family about medical details of a family history from a genetics test, which genetics tests are not useful for medical care, the pertinent genetic relationships between breast, ovarian, pancreatic, and prostate cancers and how any of these genes may affect your health.
Please join us for this positive and powerful presentation with benefits for everyone!
This presentation is sponsored by a donation from Myriad Genetics
You are invited to a Zoom meeting.
When: Aug 27, 2022 12:00 PM Eastern Time (US and Canada)
Free registration: Click Here
For Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, the Prostate Cancer Foundation, the 800-pound prostate cancer research, is holding a webinar on “Physical and Mental Wellness in Prostate Cancer.”
Here are the details:
Join us for the first in a series of monthly webinars hosted by PCF President and CEO Dr. Charles J. Ryan.
During Prostate Cancer Awareness Month, PCF challenges everyone to Get Healthy. Dr. Ryan and guests will discuss key aspects of nutrition, exercise, and mental health in prostate cancer.
The event will be on Sept. 20, 2022 04:30 PM in Pacific Time (US and Canada).
Sign up to join here.
Following each segment, there will be a live Q&A.
• Prostate 8: Simple lifestyle changes that work (Dr. Stacey Kenfield, UCSF)
Dr. Kenfield is an Associate Professor in the Department of Urology and is the Helen Diller Family Professor of Population Science for Urologic Cancer. She is an expert on lifestyle, exercise, nutrition and their impact on prostate cancer. She'll discuss research showing how specific lifestyle factors improve outcomes after prostate cancer diagnosis, and practical ways to incorporate these changes into your life.
• Mental Health and Prostate Cancer (Dr. Andrew Roth, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center)
Dr. Roth is an Attending Psychiatrist and is board-certified in Psychiatry, Geriatric Psychiatry, and Psychosomatic Medicine. He is focused on caring for the mental health needs of patients with prostate cancer and other genitourinary diseases. He'll provide an overview of the challenges patients commonly face, as well as strategies and resources for coping and living well during treatment and survivorship.
Here’s hoping Dr. Roth will cover AS as well as advanced prostate cancer.
Please send any questions for the speakers in advance to: webinar@pcf.org
I am not sure if you are surprised or are not surprised with the results of the study. It looks like you agree, and are therefore not surprised, that the level of anxiety is not significantly different for an AS patient compared to a high risk patient. You explain (correctly) that a prostatectomy is not a cure for anxiety. That is, if you are an anxious patient before you are diagnosed, you will still be an anxious patient after you are diagnosed, regardless of which category of risk the patient falls under. What I am surprised about is why the study did not mention whether the type and amount of fromage consumed by the patient correlated to the level of anxiety. For the French, eating fromage fixes everything. More cheese equals less anxiety.